This spring, the Castro Valley Municipal Advisory Council voted against a proposed children's camp on Cull Canyon Road called the Mosaic Project. So did the West County Board of Zoning Adjustments. So did Nate Miley, the Alameda County supervisor who represents Castro Valley.
Three votes against. The project was approved by three members of the five-person Alameda County Board of Supervisors who don't represent Castro Valley's district.
For buyers comparing Castro Valley with Dublin, Pleasanton, or San Leandro, the Mosaic decision illustrates how land-use decisions are made in unincorporated Castro Valley. That process differs from the city-government structure in incorporated communities.
Castro Valley has a Municipal Advisory Council, known locally as the MAC. Residents show up, they speak, sometimes for hours, and the MAC votes. The MAC is advisory only, which means the Alameda County Board of Supervisors can approve a project the MAC rejected unanimously, and did exactly that with Mosaic.
For a county land-use decision such as Mosaic, the Alameda County Board of Supervisors makes the final decision; Castro Valley is represented by one of its five members. This differs from the city-government structure in incorporated cities such as Dublin or Pleasanton.
A volunteer group called Castro Valley City Inc. has spent the past three years studying whether Castro Valley should incorporate.
Castro Valley City Inc. had announced plans for an information booth at the Castro Valley Fall Festival on Castro Valley Boulevard on September 12 and 13. Volunteers planned to explain the incorporation process and collect signatures on a petition, which is the formal first step toward a review by the Alameda County Local Agency Formation Commission, or LAFCO.
In the campaign's own announcement, Gary Howard, a board member with the group, said the campaign supports giving Castro Valley residents a greater role in decisions affecting the community. Yon Hardisty, a local nonprofit founder involved with the campaign, framed it as a chance to put the community's future "into the hands of our neighbors, friends, and family."
None of this means Castro Valley is becoming a city next year, or ever. Voters rejected incorporation in 1956 and again in 2002, when nearly 72 percent said no. The campaign's announcement of a signature-gathering effort and public event shows the governance question is live in a way it hasn't been in years. If you're evaluating this market, that context matters more than a median price.
The case for incorporation rests partly on money. Advocates point to an estimated $3 million gap each year between what Castro Valley residents pay in property taxes and what the community receives back in county services. Set against that, a 2023 LAFCO analysis estimated that running a new Castro Valley city government would cost roughly $9.36 million annually, with the new city operating at a loss for close to a decade before catching up.
The 2024 feasibility analysis LAFCO commissioned found a path to breakeven, but it depends on state legislation redirecting property tax revenue to new cities, something that hasn't happened for any California city formed since 2000. New cities are no longer eligible for the vehicle license fee revenue that used to make incorporation pencil out, and repeated attempts to restore an equivalent through Sacramento have stalled.
That's the honest state of the numbers. It's not a case for incorporation and it's not a case against it. It's a reason the community has voted no twice and is still debating whether to try a third time, and it's a reason nobody should assume this resolves quickly in either direction.
Underneath the incorporation fight sits a more immediate issue for anyone shopping near downtown Castro Valley: the Specific Plan that governs what can be built there is roughly 30 years old. Every new building or development project in downtown Castro Valley has to follow it, and it was written before BART began seriously discussing transit-oriented development at the Castro Valley BART station.
A current, locally shaped Specific Plan can help guide density toward the BART station and away from established residential streets as development plans take shape. BART's discussions of transit-oriented development around the station are another part of the planning context.
For a buyer, this cuts two ways. Property near a future transit-oriented development site can appreciate if the project delivers walkable density, new retail, and better BART access. It can also become a source of years-long uncertainty if the planning framework governing it is stale and contested. Along with checking zoning, buyers may want to follow current planning discussions around the Castro Valley BART station.
None of this should scare anyone off a neighborhood where homes were selling in a median of 13 days as of the three months ending in June 2026. It should change how you evaluate a specific parcel, especially one near downtown, near the BART station, or near open space where a project like Mosaic could recur.
A few questions are worth asking before you write an offer in one of those zones:
None of these require a law degree to check. MAC agendas and minutes are public, LAFCO's Castro Valley filings are posted online, and a title company or your agent can confirm whether a specific address sits inside an area with an active planning question attached to it. The point isn't to avoid Castro Valley. It's to know, before you're in contract, whether a nearby planning or governance issue remains under discussion at the county level.
Does the incorporation campaign affect my property taxes today? No. Nothing changes until and unless a formal incorporation measure reaches voters and passes, which has not happened in either of the last two attempts.
If Castro Valley did incorporate, would my taxes go up? That's genuinely unresolved. The 2023 and 2024 LAFCO analyses show incorporation working financially only if the state restores a revenue mechanism new cities currently don't get, so any tax outcome depends on legislation that doesn't yet exist.
Where can I track this if I'm watching a specific property? The incorporation campaign posts updates at its own site, and LAFCO's filings on Castro Valley are public through the Alameda County Local Agency Formation Commission.
Castro Valley's charm hasn't changed. What's changed is that the process deciding its next decade of development is getting more public scrutiny than it has in years, right as a major transit site sits at the center of it. If you're weighing a purchase near that conversation, Serean Kimmel can walk you through what's actually pending on a specific address before you make it yours. Get Your Free Home Valuation to start that conversation.
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.
Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today.